Schuylkill Valley Metro SVM   Project List   SEPTA  
Search

Roosevelt Boulevard Subway

Map

The Roosevelt Boulevard Corridor Study was prepared from 1999 to 2003 to examine various alternatives for improving the transportation corridor along the Roosevelt Boulevard. It included engineering and design work and public meetings to select a "preferred alternative", which ended up being a modern subway/elevated along Roosevelt Blvd that branches off the Broad Street Subway, allowing a one-seat ride into Center City. It also includes a one-mile extension of the Market-Frankford line as a subway to meet Roosevelt Blvd at Bustleton Station. There were five alternatives plus one "no build" alternative studied.

Alternative A is the "no build" or "no project" alternative.

Alternative B is the "Transportation System Management" (TSM) alternative, a.k.a. the "express bus", either in mixed traffic with automobiles or in a busway.

Alternative C is an extension of the Broad Street Line along Roosevelt Boulevard, and an extension of the Market Frankford Line to a transfer station on the Roosevelt Boulevard. This alternative would have both lines mostly underground, with the Roosevelt Blvd Subway becoming elevated north of Blue Grass Road, between Grant and Red Lion roads.

Alt C: Elevated rail north of Blue Grass Road
Alt C: Elevated rail north of Blue Grass Road

Alt C: Cottman Avenue Subway Station at the new Northeast Town Center
Alt C: Cottman Avenue Subway Station at the new Northeast Town Center

Alt C: Northeast Town Center from Above
Alt C: Northeast Town Center from above

Alternative D is an extension of the Broad Street Line along with the Roosevelt Expressway in an open cut. This would provide both a heavy-rail or "metro" transit line in the median of a four-lane expressway down the center of Roosevelt Boulevard. In some areas, the track would need to be in a tunnel or on a flyover due to site constraints.

Alt D 1
Alt D: Near Rising Sun Avenue

Alt D 2
Alt D: Near Comply Road

Alt D 3
Alt D: Center-platform stations

Alternative E is a light rail extension of the Broad Street Subway using vehicles that would run at street level along Roosevelt Boulevard, but would also run in the Broad Street Subway next to the existing subway cars.

Alt E 1
Alt E: South of Oxford Circle

Alt E 2
Alt E: Station area

Alt E 3
Alt E: Operating in mixed traffic north of Pennypack Circle

Alternative F is an extension of the Broad Street Subway along the CSX freight tracks called the "New York Short Line" (NYSL), which branches from thte R8 Fox Chase line and continues eventually to West Trenton. This would require building a crash wall and new tracks to separate freight from subway operations. This service would replace the R8 Fox Chase branch, which would be discontinued.

Alt F 1
Alt F: Freight and passenger trains on NYSL

Alt F 2
Alt F: Byberry Station

There were several document produced in this study. This is a list of the documents, available in PDF format (click on the link to open the PDF), sorted by date:

Document Date Size Length Description
Draft Final Report 2/2003 1,600 KB 57 pages This is the final report, and it contains an overview of the various alternatives considered, including renderings, descriptions, and cost analysis.
Recommendations 3/2002 212 KB 22 pages Evaluation and ranking of short-list alternatives.
Newsletter (v.2, no.1) 5/2001 256 KB 8 pages Public newsletter.
Capital Costs 2/2001 160 KB 24 pages Detailed estimates of the capital costs for each alternative, with data for how the cost estimates were made, and the results of their estimates.
Operating Costs 2/2001 148 KB 22 pages Detailed estimates of the operating costs for each alternative.
Final Definition of Alternatives 2/2001 112 KB 14 pages Refinements to alternatives since publication of the Detailed Definition in May 2000.
Detailed Definition 5/2000 184 KB 34 pages Description, scope, and details of the five alternatives in the study.
Existing Transportation Conditions and Problems 5/2000 284 KB 63 pages Describes the study corridor and existing transportation facilities and services. Also included are discussions on previous studies in the corridor, current and proposed transportation improvements and specific transportation needs.
Newsletter (v.1, no.1) 9/1999 380 KB 8 pages Public newsletter.
Evaluation Criteria and Methodology 8/1999 64 KB 13 pages Defines the criteria and methodology that will be used to screen and evaluate the various transportation alternatives.

The preferred alternative would have been the most expensive at $3.4 billion in year 2000 dollars. The second most expensive is a combination expressway and rapid transit line in an open cut, at $2.5 billion. There has been no further action to advanced this project since the study was done, and the web site which hosted these documents is no longer running.

Status: Study by Philadelphia City Planning Commission completed 3/2003
Construction start: Unknown
Construction finished: Unknown
Total cost: About $3.4 billion for subway, $2.5 billion for expressway/subway combo.

SVMetro.com
Copyright © 2006 Lucius Kwok